Skip to content

Privacy & Surveillance

France’s National Assembly votes 69 to 37 to delete encryption clause

Digital Minister Anne Le Hénanff pledged no new weakening of messaging encryption before the session ends, Tech Times reported.

https://breach-signal.com/privacy/france-deletes-encryption-clause-cybersecurity-bill/

Share

Key facts

  • On Nov. 10, France's National Assembly voted 69 to 37 to delete Article 16 bis from its cybersecurity bill.
  • Article 16 bis would have barred authorities from compelling encrypted-messaging providers to create non-consented access in their services.
  • The deleted clause is replaced by a government pledge, not a statute.
  • Digital Minister Anne Le Hénanff promised no new weakening of messaging encryption will be brought back before the session ends.

France’s National Assembly voted 69 to 37 on Nov. 10 to delete Article 16 bis from its cybersecurity bill, Tech Times reported.

The deleted clause would have barred authorities from compelling encrypted-messaging providers to create non-consented access in their services, Tech Times reported. It is replaced by a government pledge, not a statute. Digital Minister Anne Le Hénanff promised no new weakening of messaging encryption will be brought back before the session ends, and Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez repeated the commitment in the chamber on the vote day. Nuñez argued the clause was drafted too broadly and would harm intelligence methods already permitted by law.

the article was written too broadly and would undermine intelligence techniques already authorized by law.

Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez, Tech Times

Tech Times reported that Le Monde, relayed by Next.ink, said Le Hénanff also pledged not to support bringing back Article 8 ter. Article 8 ter, a prior Senate measure, would have compelled messaging apps to grant police access to conversations. The commitment applies only until the parliamentary session ends rather than to a set calendar date.

Tech Times reported that lawmakers did not keep Article 8 ter in the narcotics law. No French law currently obliges encrypted-messaging providers to include a backdoor. Article 16 bis never took effect, meaning no statute has ever prohibited such an order. Removing the clause leaves the legal position unchanged.

Tech Times explained the technical stakes. With end-to-end encryption, unlocking keys stay on users’ devices, meaning providers transport messages without reading them. Requiring readable content would force changes such as a provider-held master key, a hidden chat participant, or pre-encryption device inspection. Each option creates a route attackers and authorized officials alike can exploit.

Tech Times reported that a Florent Boudié-led mission, created by a Jan. 21 decree, issued a report on encrypted-communication access. Tech Times also reported that Next.ink said the report recommends dropping Article 16 bis because its language creates serious legal gray areas.

Tech Times reported that on May 4, 2026, the parliamentary intelligence delegation called targeted access for intelligence and judicial services legitimate, necessary and technically possible. Delegation member Agnès Canayer said messaging providers warned that targeted access would weaken the reliability their business model relies on. No draft statute, specification or design for targeted access has been published, so its security properties cannot be assessed.

Tech Times reported that the European Court of Human Rights reasoned that decrypting those chats would weaken encryption for every user. In Podchasov v. Russia, decided Feb. 13, 2024, the court unanimously ruled that forced decryption of encrypted chats violated private life. The Center for Democracy and Technology described the ruling as a warning to EU lawmakers.

Tech Times noted that the 1990s US Clipper chip proposed key escrow, and researcher Matt Blaze defeated its escrow check in 1994. Reported Salt Typhoon intrusions into US telecom networks reached systems used for lawful wiretapping. That intrusion demonstrates that access infrastructure is itself a target.

Tech Times reported that senators inserted Article 16 bis into the resilience bill they adopted in March 2025 despite government opposition. Senator Olivier Cadic placed the clause in the Senate text responding to Article 8 ter of the narcotics-trafficking bill. Lawmakers took Article 8 ter out, and the narcotics law was promulgated on June 13, 2025.

Tech Times reported that AFP characterized the clause as a counter-measure to Article 8 ter. ANSSI head Vincent Strubel told the special commission in July 2025 that retaining Article 16 bis might be unnecessary after Article 8 ter’s removal. The parliamentary intelligence delegation separately warned that the clause posed a major risk.

Tech Times reported that lead rapporteur Éric Bothorel said the measure would create difficulties for investigators. Special commission chair Philippe Latombe said rejecting Article 16 bis does not, alone, authorize backdoors. Most Socialist deputies also supported removing the clause. Latombe’s remark and Nuñez’s pledge express intent rather than a legal ban.

Tech Times reported that Green deputy Catherine Hervieu opposed removal, saying encryption is a condition of security, not an obstacle to it. Socialist deputy Ayda Hadizadeh supported deletion but regretted that no article could permanently ban backdoors.

Tech Times reported that Le Hénanff was rapporteure for the NIS2 title of the bill in the Assembly’s special commission. She, Bothorel and Latombe signed a March 2025 column warning about Article 8 ter’s dangers. Laurent Nuñez, the former Paris police prefect, said the rejected access measure was a missed opportunity after prison attacks. The special commission rejected Éric Bothorel’s amendment to rewrite Article 16 bis.

Tech Times reported that the broader bill transposes three EU instruments: DORA for finance, NIS2 on cybersecurity and the critical-entities resilience directive. France missed the Oct. 17, 2024 transposition deadline, prompting the European Commission to refer the country to court on July 8, 2026. Individual users face no direct regulation.

Tech Times reported that deputies will hold a solemn vote on the whole bill on Tuesday, Nov. 17. The outlet also reported that LCP expects the same vote. A joint committee of seven deputies and seven senators might be convened to reconcile the two chambers’ versions. Implementing decrees will establish concrete rules for the new duties.

Tech Times reported that a statute binds the executive until repeal, whereas the pledge is a political commitment lasting only until the session ends. A future government could propose new rules after the pledge expires, pending a Parliamentary vote. Targeted access lets intelligence and judicial services reach protected content in specific cases instead of creating a general path into all conversations.

The encryption issue determines whether authorities might someday order messaging apps to grant access. Technology site Korben characterized the agreement in a headline as the state retreating without truly relinquishing control.

Was this helpful?

Join the discussion

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting. First-time comments are held for moderation. By posting a comment you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which explain how your name, email address and comment are used.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *