Skip to content

Cybercrime

RansomwareHelp co-founder Palacio faces wire fraud charge after FBI sting

The FBI sting found RansomwareHelp paid attackers for decryption keys and charged victims a markup for decryption work never performed.

https://breach-signal.com/cybercrime/ransomwarehelp-co-founder-palacio-wire-fraud-charge/

Share

Key facts

  • RansomwareHelp said it used advanced cryptographic tools to unlock ransomware-locked data.
  • The FBI sting found the company paid attackers for decryption keys and charged victims a markup for decryption work never performed.
  • RansomwareHelp's website told victims not to pay the ransom and claimed advanced cryptographic tools could return all data servers and systems to their pre-attack state.
  • Website said paying extortion demands was unnecessary.

Juan Ricardo Palacio Escobar, 52, was the chief technology officer and a co-founder of RansomwareHelp, and he now faces a wire fraud charge after an indictment was returned this week in Rhode Island, KrebsonSecurity reported.

RansomwareHelp, a Florida business six years old, pitched ransomware victims on advanced cryptographic tools to unlock their data. Its website said paying extortion demands was unnecessary and promised complete data recovery with a success rate above 99 percent using proprietary tools and algorithms. The site also claimed more than 28 years in business, a staff of 80 specialists working in security and cryptography, and a policy of never promoting ransom payments to threat actors or paying them for clients.

The indictment says Palacio routinely paid ransomware cartels for decryption keys, and the amounts he charged victims far exceeded the hidden sums paid to the attackers. In the FBI sting, investigators pretended to be a ransomware victim and also posed as a fake ransomware cartel. Agents sent RansomwareHelp a fake ransom note and said they would not pay any ransom, and the company said it never negotiates with threat actors or pays ransoms.

Palacio contacted the FBI’s fake ransomware cartel and asked what the cheapest decryptor would cost. FBI investigators put the price at .2 bitcoin, about $13,000 at the time. Less than 48 hours later, he told undercover agents posing as employees of the victim company that the diagnostic was a success and that unlocking the data would cost $13,260. The next day, Palacio messaged the fake cartel and asked it to lower the ransom to $4,000 for a decryption tool.

The indictment stated the settled price was about $6,000 in bitcoin. Palacio billed the fake victim company $16,010, made up of a $2,750 diagnostic fee plus the $13,260 fee, for decryption work the FBI says was never performed.

Paul Ihme co-founded the security company Soteria. He said that in 2024 Lockbit ransomware locked all of a small accounting firm’s company and client data, and that the firm paid RansomwareHelp a diagnostic fee.

The proposal put recovery at $438,880 and said the price covered setup of forensic servers, hours of programming for decryption algorithms and eight six-hour processing cycles. It said programmers would use brute force methods to reverse engineer the ransomware encryption with 510 preconfigured forensic servers worldwide, randomly inserting encryption codes based on forensic and cryptographic analysis.

RansomwareHelp demanded unrestricted remote access to the victim’s network by way of an AnyDesk installer so it could run diagnostics and analysis. In Ihme’s view, the goal was partly to wipe all of the attackers’ ransom notes off the victim’s network. The review found only one ransom note copy, taken from a backup snapshot of an infected computer.

After joining the Lockbit chat server with the user ID supplied by RansomwareHelp, Ihme found that the extortionists had already been negotiating for several days. In that chat, RansomwareHelp pleaded with Lockbit not to tell the victim that the two sides were negotiating. Lockbit said the victims had waited too long, so the demand would increase $100,000 per day of further delay.

The accounting firm followed Ihme’s advice and hired a different security company to negotiate with Lockbit. The final payment came to half of RansomwareHelp’s quoted price. Chat records show RansomwareHelp kept pressing Lockbit to negotiate even after another negotiator had taken over on the victim’s side, saying the outside negotiator was damaging the process and asking Lockbit to keep the price unchanged.

Ihme said RansomwareHelp mostly went after small and medium businesses without strong technical skills, and he called the technical claims on its website and in its proposal absurd. He said the proposal claimed to defeat six kinds of encryption, yet its list of algorithms included unrelated hashing tools such as SHA-256. Ihme said that anyone able to decrypt any ransomware would be a billionaire; the victims, in his view, lacked technical knowledge, were desperate and had no expert advice.

In early October, Edward Dubrovsky, 54, a Cybersteward executive in Canada, was charged with cyber extortion and conspiracy; the case remains sealed. At about the same time, the Justice Department charged Zohar Pinhasi, 50, MonsterCloud’s chief, with wire fraud and conspiracy for claiming that MonsterCloud could fix ransomware attacks without paying the attackers. Court papers allege he paid ransomware cartels $8 million while billing customers $19 million.

In July, Angelo Martino, 41, of Land O’Lakes, Florida, received a 70-month prison sentence for conspiring with the Blackcat/ALPHV ransomware cartel to extort victims. According to the Justice Department, BlackCat attackers paid Martino for confidential details about client negotiations so the cartel could raise victim payments.

Was this helpful?

Join the discussion

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting. First-time comments are held for moderation. By posting a comment you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which explain how your name, email address and comment are used.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *