Key facts
- The UK Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled the government must confirm it issued a secret technical capability notice to Apple demanding access to encrypted customer data.
- The tribunal rejected the Home Office argument that confirming the notice would damage national security.
- The tribunal said the government had not established that revealing Apple received a technical capability notice would damage national security.
- A technical capability notice under the Investigatory Powers Act lets UK security services access encrypted customer data by forcing companies to change their products.
The UK Investigatory Powers Tribunal, hearing the case Sept. 17, 2026, ruled that the government must confirm it issued a secret technical capability notice to Apple demanding access to encrypted customer data.
The tribunal rejected the Home Office argument that confirming the notice would damage national security, finding that officials had not established that revealing Apple received the order would cause harm. Judges said people following the dispute already knew about the notice, and the panel called the idea that acknowledgment would help malicious actors fanciful.
The hearing was before Lady Carmichael, Mr Justice Chamberlain and Mr Justice Johnson. The ruling allows much of Apple’s and the non-profits’ legal challenge to proceed in open court.
A technical capability notice under the Investigatory Powers Act lets UK security services access encrypted customer data by forcing companies to change their products. The government reportedly ordered Apple in 2025 to create a backdoor for access to customer data anywhere in the world.
The original demand was later narrowed to cover British nationals’ data in Apple’s encrypted cloud, and Apple challenged this second order. Apple took legal action in July after the Home Office issued a second technical capability notice. The Home Office withdrew an earlier demand covering UK and US customers after a dispute with the American government, and officials believe the replacement notice targets UK users only.
Apple declined the demand and prevented UK customers from enabling Advanced Data Protection for iCloud rather than complying. Apple stopped offering Advanced Data Protection to new UK users in February 2025. “We are gravely disappointed that the protections provided by ADP will not be available to our customers in the UK,” Apple said.
UK customers who had not enabled ADP can no longer activate it, and Apple says it cannot switch off ADP for users, so the feature remains active on accounts where customers enabled it and have not disabled it. Apple said affected customers will get a period to disable ADP themselves to keep using iCloud, but no deadline has been set.
Without ADP, those iCloud data categories use standard protection, under which Apple holds the keys and can respond to valid legal demands. iMessage, FaceTime, passwords, and Health data remain end-to-end encrypted by default. Apple said 10 end-to-end encrypted iCloud categories are unavailable to new UK users: iCloud Backup, iCloud Drive, Photos, Notes, Reminders, Safari Bookmarks, Siri Shortcuts, Voice Memos, Wallet Passes, and Freeform.
Apple said it has never created a backdoor or master key for its products or services and will never do so. The company claims the Investigatory Powers Act’s technical capability notice power cannot force a company to change product security or privacy, and that the order is disproportionate. Apple also said forcing iPhone encryption weaker for UK authorities might lower security standards for users worldwide.

Liberty International brought the challenge for two individuals. Privacy International and Liberty filed a separate challenge alongside Apple’s case, and Privacy International scheduled its separate challenge’s substantive hearing for December 2026. The hearing set for December 2026 is impractical, and the parties now plan a substantive hearing in the first half of 2027.
A final hearing on which order details can be released is expected next year. The substance of the technical capability notice remains secret for now, with details to be decided later.
The tribunal found that media leaks and talks with US officials had already broken the government’s neither confirm nor deny policy. “anyone with even a passing interest in this topic already knows that the respondent has served a technical capability notice on Apple,” the tribunal said. The department’s documents carried an OFFICIAL SENSITIVE marking instead of SECRET or TOP SECRET.
The tribunal found the Home Office formally maintains neither confirm nor deny while informally briefing journalists to shape a narrative, and judges said ministers or senior officials authorized those briefings. Neil Sheldon KC argued for the government that confirmation would set a damaging precedent, but the tribunal rejected this. Andrew Scurry of the Home Office said the neither confirm nor deny principle works only if applied consistently.
The Home Office said it investigated the media leaks, but judges ruled the probe had little evidential value without more detail. Privacy International said the government cannot claim secrecy in court while leaking to the press for political or diplomatic reasons. Liberty director Akiko Hart said the UK should strengthen encryption rather than weaken it because cyber threats are growing. Liberty praised the ruling.
Apple asked the tribunal to let it discuss the order publicly, and privacy campaigners supported the request. Apple went to court to demand public confirmation of the order and an end to secrecy rules. Apple told TechCrunch it welcomes the decision to make public the fact that the U.K. Home Office issued a technical capability notice. A Home Office spokesperson did not respond to TechCrunch’s request for comment, and the department has not confirmed the notice exists.
White House officials and US lawmakers criticized the UK order, saying it would put Americans’ privacy at risk. “this is the first known time that the government has been compelled to confirm the existence of a secret technical order,” Liberty International said.

Join the discussion